|Anonymous | Login | Signup for a new account||2018-01-17 10:18 PST|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Roadmap|
|View Issue Details|
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0000435||Core Inform||Properties||public||2010-11-23 22:28||2014-05-07 07:35|
|Target Version||Fixed in Version||6L02|
|Summary||0000435: Including spurious "called X" in kind-named property definition fails to compile and produces unhelpful error message.|
|Description||The problem with the code below is that the text "called theme" is redundant. It would be more natural for the compiler to ignore unnecessary phrases or to throw out a warning, especially given I7's natural language leanings. |
But if only the error message can be changed, then something like this would be more helpful:
Problem. The sentence "Movie is a thing. Movie has a theme called theme." uses "called theme" but those words are not needed for properties that have the same name as kinds (in this case, "theme"). Instead, you should write "Movie is a thing. Movie has a theme."
Problem. The sentence 'The themes are good and bad' appears to say two things are the same - I am reading 'themes' and 'good' as two different things, and therefore it makes no sense to say that one is the other: it would be like saying that 'Choucas is Hibou'. It would be all right if the second thing were the name of a kind, perhaps with properties: for instance 'The Hall is a lighted room' says that something called The Hall exists and that it is a 'room', which is a kind I know about, combined with a property called 'lighted' which I also know about.
Problem. You wrote 'Movie has a theme called theme' , but 'theme' is not the name of a kind of value which I know (such as 'number' or 'text').
See the manual: 4.8 > New value properties
|Minimal Source Text To Reproduce|
Sanitarium is a room. Theme is a kind of value. The themes are good and bad. Movie is a thing. Movie has a theme called theme.
|Tags||No tags attached.|
|Effect||(cosmetic) Error message is badly worded|
Not many people will run into this, but I've added a problem:
You wrote 'Movie has a theme called theme': but the 'called' here appears to be unnecessary, and this sentence should be simplified. For example, 'A door has a number called number' is not allowed: it should be just 'A door has a number', or something more specific like 'A door has a number called the street number'.
|2010-11-23 22:28||Poster||New Issue|
|2010-11-23 23:10||jmcgrew||Status||new => confirmed|
|2010-12-19 15:34||jmcgrew||Relationship added||has duplicate 0000477|
|2010-12-19 15:36||jmcgrew||Category||Kinds and type checking => Properties|
|2010-12-19 15:36||jmcgrew||Summary||Including spurious "called X" in object definition fails to compile and produces unhelpful error message. => Including spurious "called X" in kind-named property definition fails to compile and produces unhelpful error message.|
|2011-10-16 07:26||graham||Note Added: 0001397|
|2011-10-16 07:26||graham||Status||confirmed => resolved|
|2011-10-16 07:26||graham||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2011-10-16 07:26||graham||Assigned To||=> graham|
|2014-05-07 07:34||jmcgrew||Fixed in Version||=> 6L02|
|2014-05-07 07:35||jmcgrew||Status||resolved => closed|
|Copyright © 2000 - 2010 MantisBT Group|